Supreme Court of the United States
Jefferson v. Upton
May 24, 2010560 U.S. 284
Summary
The Court held per curiam that the Eleventh Circuit improperly treated record support as sufficient to require deference to state-court factual findings under pre-AEDPA habeas law without considering Jefferson’s challenges to the fairness of the state factfinding process. Any of the eight statutory exceptions could defeat the presumption of correctness. The Court vacated and remanded for consideration of whether the findings warranted that presumption, without deciding whether an exception actually applied or whether counsel rendered ineffective assistance. Justice Scalia, joined by Justice Thomas, dissented, arguing that the statutory issue was neither properly presented nor decided below and that the Eleventh Circuit had not treated record support as the exclusive statutory exception. He preferred denying certiorari.
Holding
- Application of the pre-AEDPA presumption of correctness to state-court findings challenged on procedural-fairness grounds.. The Eleventh Circuit erred by treating §2254(d)(8) as the exclusive exception to the presumption of correctness and failing to consider Jefferson’s challenges implicating the statutory exceptions concerning the adequacy and fairness of state proceedings.
Docket 09-8852
Cited authorities
- 28 U.S.C. §§2254
- CA11
- CA11
- CA11
- 28 U. S. C. §2254
- 28 U. S. C. §2254
- 28 U. S. C. §2254
- 28 U. S. C. §2254
Cited by
- Brandon Astor Jones, Petitioner-Appellant v. Gdcp Warden, Respondent-Appellee
- Jonathan Marcus Green, Appellant v. the State of Texas
- Ex Parte Steven Anthony Butler, Applicant — Price, J., Dissenting
- Grose v. Commissioner of Social Security
- Dockery v. Commissioner of Social Security
- Bowling v. Commissioner of Social Security
- Garrett v. Commissioner of Social Security
- Clark v. Commissioner of Social Security