Supreme Court of the United States
Halbert v. Michigan
June 23, 2005545 U.S. 605
Summary
The Court held that indigent defendants convicted by guilty or nolo contendere pleas must receive appointed counsel when seeking first-tier review in the Michigan Court of Appeals. Although the application for leave to appeal is formally discretionary, the Court of Appeals evaluates the applicant's particular claims and provides the first and likely only direct review, making the proceeding functionally comparable to an initial appeal as of right. The Court therefore vacated the Michigan Court of Appeals' judgment and remanded. Justice Thomas, dissenting, would have upheld Michigan's system because the review was discretionary and Halbert knowingly waived any right to appointed appellate counsel.
Holding
- Constitutional entitlement to counsel for first-tier review. The Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses require Michigan to appoint counsel for indigent defendants convicted by guilty or nolo contendere pleas who seek first-tier review in the Michigan Court of Appeals.
- Waiver of appointed appellate counsel. Halbert did not waive the right to appointed counsel for first-tier review by entering his plea because, when he pleaded, he had no recognized right to appointed appellate counsel that he could knowingly elect to forgo, and the plea colloquy did not clearly advise him that counsel would be unavailable in his circumstances.
Docket 03-10198
Cited authorities
- Rule 7.205
- 28 U. S. C. §2111
- Rule 7.205(D)(2)
- Rule 7.205(D)(3)
- Rule 6.425(E)(2)(a)
- Rule 7.205(D)(2)
- Rule 7.302(B)(2)
- Rule 10