Supreme Court of the United States

Lewis v. Lewis & Clark Marine, Inc.

February 21, 2001531 U.S. 438

Summary

Justice O'Connor delivered the unanimous opinion holding that the District Court properly exercised its discretion by dissolving an injunction against a seaman's state-court personal injury action after protecting the vessel owner's right to seek limitation of liability. The Limitation Act does not provide a freestanding right to federal adjudication of exoneration when limitation is not at issue, and the saving to suitors clause preserves remedies beyond jury trials. The claimant's stipulations and the District Court's retention of jurisdiction adequately protected the owner's limitation rights. The Court reversed the Eighth Circuit and remanded. There were no separate opinions.

Holding

  • Discretion to dissolve an injunction against state-court litigation while retaining a limitation proceeding.. The District Court acted within its discretion in dissolving the injunction because the vessel owner's right to seek limitation of liability was adequately protected.
  • Whether the Limitation Act guarantees a federal forum for exoneration independently of limitation.. The Limitation Act and its procedural rules do not create a freestanding right to exoneration from liability in federal court where limitation of liability is not at issue.
  • Whether saved state-court remedies depend on a demand for a jury trial.. The saving to suitors clause preserves remedies beyond jury trial and permits state courts to adjudicate these personal injury claims when the owner's limitation rights are protected.

Docket 99-1331

Cited authorities

Cited by

Read full opinionPDF