Supreme Court of the United States
Railway Employes’ Department, American Federation of Labor v. Hanson
May 21, 1956351 U.S. 225
Summary
The Court held that Congress could authorize union-shop agreements in the railroad industry under the Commerce Clause and could provide that those agreements would prevail over inconsistent state right-to-work laws. The requirement that employees financially support the collective-bargaining representative did not violate the First or Fifth Amendments because the authorized payments were limited to dues, initiation fees, and assessments related to collective bargaining. Justice Frankfurter, concurring, emphasized that the constitutional challenge principally raised a policy question concerning Congress's regulation of interstate railroad labor relations.
Holding
- Federal preemption of Nebraska's right-to-work law. A union-shop agreement made pursuant to the Railway Labor Act cannot be invalidated or made illegal by a conflicting state law because the federal statute expressly authorizes such agreements notwithstanding state law.
- Congress's Commerce Clause authority. Congress may authorize union-shop agreements in the interstate railroad industry as an appropriate means of promoting industrial peace and stabilizing labor-management relations.
- First Amendment challenge. Requiring employees who receive the benefits of collective bargaining to provide financial support through periodic dues, initiation fees, and qualifying assessments does not, on the record presented, violate the First Amendment.
- Fifth Amendment challenge. The authorized union-shop requirement does not violate the Fifth Amendment.
Docket 451
Cited authorities
- 45 U.S.C. § 152
- 64 Stat. 1238
- 28 U.S.C. § 1257
- 48 Stat. 1186
- 45 U.S.C. § 152
- 64 Stat. 1238
- 25 Stat. 501
- 30 Stat. 424
Cited by
- Thomas J. Barksdale v. Director of the Division of Employment Security & another
- Washington Legal Foundation v. Massachusetts Bar Foundation
- Fred Z. Mills, Jr. v. Braniff Airways, Inc.
- New Orleans Steamship Association, a Corporation, and Ttt Stevedores of Louisiana, Inc., a Corporation v. General…
- Pegues v. International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers
- Rosangelica Acevedo-Delgado, Plaintiff, Appellee v. Miguel A. Rivera, Defendant, Appellant; Rosangelica…
- Robert Lavoie, Plaintiff-Appellant v. James Bigwood, Defendants-Appellees
- Barbara Fletcher v. Rhode Island Hospital Trust National Bank…