Most-Cited Cases in U.S. Courts, 2024–2026

· LawDiver

Most-Cited Cases in U.S. Courts, 2024–2026

LawDiver Enterprise brings you the power to directly query the entire corpus of federal and state caselaw, as well as every federal and state statute, and the CFR. Complex queries can provide real, actionable intelligence, available nowhere else. You can run the database in your own private instance on our hardware. Or, the best part: run a copy of the database, updated nightly, on your own hardware. Total Privacy. Total Security. Run your own queries, legal apps, and cite checking on your own hardware, with your apps or our open-source apps that you can modify. This is the solution that enterprise has been waiting for all year. Reach out at [email protected] to learn more.

Here are some simple examples of Big Data for Enterprise.

Most cited cases in published federal circuit opinions

Published circuit decisions: 3,486 filed in 2024, 3,640 in 2025, and 2,701 in 2026 through October 6. The list below is every federal court of appeals.

2026, through October 6

Gall and Winter are tied for sixth. Share is citing decisions divided by 2,701 published circuit decisions.

2025

Share uses 3,640 published circuit decisions. Bruen reaches 128 citing decisions here, its high for these three years. It was ninth in 2024 and is ninth again in 2026.

2024

Share uses 3,486 published circuit decisions. Spokeo is in the 2024 ten and then drops out, while TransUnion stays. Graham v. Connor enters the ten in 2026. Monell is eighth in 2024 and 2025.

A published circuit opinion is often a merits, sentencing, or justiciability decision. Iqbal and Twombly are cited by about one published circuit decision in seventeen. Olano and Gall are there because the courts of appeals review criminal sentences and forfeited arguments. Pearson is there because qualified immunity is still briefed.

Most cited cases in published federal district opinions

Published district decisions: 1,141 filed in 2024, 1,417 in 2025, and 1,210 in 2026 through October 5.

2026, through October 5

Iqbal is in nearly one published district opinion in three. Twombly is close behind. Hagans, Neitzke, Newburyport, and Denton are the cases courts use when a complaint can be dismissed for want of jurisdiction or as frivolous. Hettinga states a Rule 12(b)(6) standard.

2025

Share uses 1,417 published district decisions.

2024

Share uses 1,141 published district decisions. Da Costa was decided in 2023 and is already in the 2024 ten.

Iqbal is about 6 percent of published circuit decisions and 25 to 32 percent of published district decisions. District opinions in this window are often deciding whether a complaint states a claim. Circuit opinions are often deciding standing, a sentence, or a forfeited argument, which is why Olano, Gall, and Lujan sit where they do.

How often state high courts cite federal cases

The window is opinions filed from January 1, 2025, through the latest decision on file: September 24, 2026 for the California and Illinois supreme courts, September 25 for the Texas Supreme Court, and June 23 for the New York Court of Appeals. A decision counts if it cites at least one federal court decision.

Court20252026 year to date2025–2026
Texas Supreme Court41 of 78 (53%)43 of 72 (60%)84 of 150 (56%)
California Supreme Court32 of 45 (71%)31 of 44 (70%)63 of 89 (71%)
Illinois Supreme Court31 of 45 (69%)18 of 28 (64%)49 of 73 (67%)
New York Court of Appeals62 of 126 (49%)26 of 66 (39%)88 of 192 (46%)

Most of those cites are to the U.S. Supreme Court: about 82 percent of California's federal case-pairs, 74 percent of New York's, 73 percent of the Texas Supreme Court's, and 71 percent of Illinois's.

Texas Supreme Court

Nine federal cases were cited in three or more Texas Supreme Court decisions. Eighteen further federal cases were cited in exactly two decisions, so there is no unique tenth case.

Santosky is the clear-and-convincing burden for terminating parental rights. Mullane and Jones v. Flowers are notice. Olano is plain error. Lujan, Steel Co., and Stevens are standing. Bonner Mall is vacatur when a case ends in a settlement. Marbury is cited three times.

California Supreme Court

Every federal case cited in six or more decisions is in this table. Chapman and Apprendi are tied for first.

The list is criminal: harmless error, the jury's role in sentencing (Apprendi, Ring, Blakely, and Cunningham), Batson, Roper, Miranda, death qualification (Witt), and confrontation (Crawford).

Illinois Supreme Court

No federal case is cited in more than three of 73 decisions. Three cases are tied at three. Ten more are tied at two. A top-ten cutoff would drop Strickland, TransUnion, and Williams v. Pennsylvania, which have the same count as cases that would have made an arbitrary ten. All thirteen are below.

Miller, Weaver, and Bruen lead a flat field. One or two opinions move the rank.

New York Court of Appeals

Six federal cases were cited in three or more decisions. Twenty-one more were cited in exactly two. The six that clear three cites:

Landgraf and Pension Benefit Guaranty are retroactivity. Hallock is stare decisis. Santobello and Faretta are pleas and the right to self-representation. Erlinger was decided in 2024 and is already tied for second.

Why the lists diverge

The lists follow the docket.

Published circuit opinions cite Iqbal in about 6 percent of decisions. Published district opinions cite it in 25 to 32 percent. Twombly tracks it. Trial courts are publishing opinions that decide whether a complaint states a claim. Appellate courts are publishing opinions on standing (Lujan, TransUnion, Spokeo), plain error (Olano), sentencing (Gall), qualified immunity (Pearson), injunctions (Winter), municipal liability (Monell), guns (Bruen), and, in 2026, excessive force (Graham).

State high courts cite the federal cases their own docket requires. The California Supreme Court cites Chapman and Apprendi in 15 of 89 decisions, then the rest of a criminal and capital list. The Texas Supreme Court is the civil court of last resort. Its repeating federal cases are parental rights, notice, and standing.

Criminal cases in Texas go to the Court of Criminal Appeals, which cited a federal decision in 47 of 100 decisions in 2025 and 22 of 43 in 2026, 69 of 143 combined (48 percent). The cases cited in four or more of those decisions:

Brady v. United States is the guilty-plea case. Brady v. Maryland is a different case. A longer tier at three citing decisions includes Brady v. Maryland, Katz, Terry, Carpenter, and Apprendi. The two Texas courts of last resort produce two federal lists.

Illinois cites a federal case about as often as California, in 49 of 73 decisions, and no federal case is cited more than three times. Bruen can lead a court that hears a gun case. Rank past the first few names, in a court that decides fewer than a hundred cases a year, moves when one opinion moves.

The New York Court of Appeals cites a federal case in 88 of 192 decisions, the smallest share of the four courts. When a federal case repeats, it is Landgraf, a plea case, or Erlinger. A 2024 Supreme Court holding is already in that court's working set.

Year to year, in the circuits, Iqbal, Lujan, and Twombly do not change places. Bruen climbs from ninth in 2024 to fourth in 2025 and is ninth again in 2026. Spokeo leaves the ten after 2024. Graham enters it in 2026.

These tables are one query against the citation graph. LawDiver Enterprise is how you run the next one, on our service or on a nightly copy you keep yourself.

Frequently asked questions

What case is cited most in federal circuit courts in 2024, 2025, and 2026?

Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662 (2009). It is first in published circuit opinions in each of those years: 200 of 3,486 decisions in 2024, 227 of 3,640 in 2025, and 155 of 2,701 in 2026 through October 6. Lujan and Twombly are second and third in all three years.

What case is cited most in federal district courts in 2026?

Iqbal again, in 382 of 1,210 published district decisions filed through October 5, 2026 (31.6 percent). Twombly is second, in 328.

How often does the Texas Supreme Court cite federal cases?

In 84 of 150 published decisions filed in 2025 and 2026 (56 percent): 41 of 78 in 2025 and 43 of 72 in 2026. The federal cases cited in three or more of those decisions are Santosky, Mullane, Olano, Marbury, Lujan, Bonner Mall, Stevens, Jones v. Flowers, and Steel Co.. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals cited a federal decision in 69 of 143 decisions over the same window, led by Brady v. United States, Jackson v. Virginia, and Strickland.

Why do California and Texas cite different federal cases?

The California Supreme Court cites Chapman, Apprendi, Ring, Blakely, Batson, Roper, Miranda, Witt, Crawford, and Cunningham. Those match a published docket that still decides criminal procedure and capital cases. The Texas Supreme Court is the civil court of last resort, and its repeating federal cases are parental rights, notice, plain error, and standing. Texas criminal cases go to the Court of Criminal Appeals, whose repeating federal cases are Brady v. United States, Jackson v. Virginia, Strickland, Gates, Riley, and United States v. Jones.

Does this ranking include the U.S. Code?

It counts citations to federal court decisions. A citation to a statute or to the CFR is a separate query. LawDiver Enterprise can run that query too. Reach [email protected].

Most-Cited Cases in U.S. Courts, 2024–2026 | LawDiver