Nevada Supreme Court

Anthony Frederick Passarelli, Appellant v. the State of Nevada, Respondent

May 23, 197793 Nev. 292

Summary

The court affirmed appellant's second-degree murder conviction, rejecting challenges to the admission of deceased and unavailable witnesses' testimony, the admission of a prior inconsistent statement, and the refusal to give two requested jury instructions. It held that the deceased witness's preliminary-hearing testimony was admissible, any error concerning the prior inconsistent statement was harmless in light of overwhelming evidence, and the requested instructions were adequately covered by other instructions.

Holding

  • Admission of deceased witness's preliminary-hearing testimony. The district court properly admitted the witness's preliminary-hearing testimony because her death made her unavailable, and the asserted unreliability of her testimony concerned credibility and weight rather than admissibility. The court also found no abuse of discretion in balancing probative value against prejudicial effect.
  • Admission of testimony concerning the unavailable witness's prior inconsistent statement. Even assuming the district court erred by admitting the detective's testimony concerning the prior inconsistent statement for its truth, the error was harmless because the jury's verdict was supported by other overwhelming evidence of guilt.
  • Refusal to give proposed instructions on testimony's weight and credibility. The district court did not err by refusing the two proposed instructions because their subject matter was substantially covered by other instructions given to the jury.

Docket 9054

Cited by

Read full opinionPDF