District of Columbia Court of Appeals
John C. Young, Appellant v. United States, Appellee
August 17, 1978391 A.2d 248
Summary
The court affirmed appellant’s second-degree murder conviction. It held that the decedent’s statements to police were admissible as spontaneous utterances because they were made shortly after a serious stabbing while the decedent was bleeding, excited, and repeatedly seeking revenge. It also held that the trial court was not required to give a cautionary instruction regarding the reliability or weight of dying declarations, and that such an instruction could improperly comment on the evidence.
Holding
- Admissibility of the decedent’s statements to police. The statements were properly admitted as spontaneous utterances because the decedent was suffering from a serious, ultimately fatal wound, was found shortly after the stabbing in an agitated and excited condition, and made repeated statements without apparent opportunity for reflection.
- Cautionary instruction concerning dying declarations. The trial court did not commit reversible error by declining to give an immediate cautionary instruction after the first witness’s testimony. No such instruction was required, and an instruction directing the jury about the purported dangers or proper weight of dying-declaration testimony would constitute an unwarranted comment on the evidence.
Docket 10444
Cited by
- United States, Appellant and Cross-Appellee v. Floyd C. Woodfolk, Appellee and Cross-Appellant
- Andre T. Price, Appellant v. United States, Appellee
- Clyde Simmons, Appellant v. United States, Appellee
- Mark K. Harrison, Appellant v. United States, Appellee
- Ester T. Hairston, Appellant v. United States, Appellee
- Damon Q. Smith, Appellant v. United States, Appellee
- Sean B. Butler, Appellant v. United States, Appellee
- Richard L. Lyons, A/k/a Walter Lyons, Appellant v. United States, Appellee; Pamela K. Cooper, Appellant, v. United…