E.D. v. Noblesville School District

Summary

The Court denied certiorari without addressing the merits of a student's First Amendment challenge to her school's refusal to approve club flyers containing photographs of students holding anti-abortion advocacy placards. Justice Alito dissented, with no other Justice joining his opinion. He would have granted review to clarify the relationship between Hazelwood's standard for school-sponsored expression and the Court's subsequent government-speech decisions, emphasizing the importance of distinguishing private student expression from speech attributable to a school.