Supreme Court of the United States
Evans v. Michigan
February 20, 2013568 U.S. 313
Summary
The Supreme Court reversed the Michigan Supreme Court, holding that the Double Jeopardy Clause bars retrial after a trial court grants a directed verdict of acquittal, even if the acquittal rests on an erroneous understanding of the statutory elements. Justice Alito dissented, arguing that an acquittal must resolve actual elements of the offense to trigger double jeopardy protection.
Holding
- Double Jeopardy and erroneous acquittal. The Double Jeopardy Clause bars retrial after a court-decreed acquittal even if based on an error of law regarding statutory elements.
Docket 11-1327
Cited authorities
- Rule 29(a) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure
- Mich. Comp. Laws §750.73
- Mich. Comp. Laws §750.72
- Mich. Comp. Laws §750.72
- Mich. Comp. Laws §750.73
- 18 U. S. C. §2113
- Nev. Rev. Stat. §175.381
- Mich. Comp. Laws §750.72
Cited by
- Com. v. Martin, M. Jr.
- Labrador v. Idaho State Board of Education
- Ryan Marshall, Petitioner, Appellee v. Bristol Superior Court, Respondent, Appellant
- Tatara v. Secretary, Department of Corrections
- Wilkins v. Warden
- Doris H. Usie v. Sunshine Homes, Inc.
- State of Montana, and v. Craig Alan Barrows, and
- In the Matter of C.c.w., a Youth. State of Oregon v. C. C. W.