Supreme Court of the United States

Bay Area Laundry and Dry Cleaning Pension Trust Fund v. Ferbar Corporation of California, Inc.

December 15, 1997522 U.S. 192

Summary

Justice Ginsburg delivered the Court’s opinion holding that the MPPAA’s six-year limitations period for collecting withdrawal liability begins when an employer misses a scheduled payment, not when it withdraws from the pension plan. Each missed installment creates a separate cause of action with its own limitations period, and the plan need not accelerate the debt to preserve claims for future installments. The Fund waived recovery of the first installment by representing in its certiorari petition that recovery depended on resolving the conflict over separate installment accrual, rather than arguing that its claim for that installment was independently timely. The Court reversed the Ninth Circuit and remanded, permitting recovery proceedings for subsequent installments. There were no separate opinions.

Holding

  • When the limitations period begins for an action to collect withdrawal liability.. The six-year limitations period begins only after the trustees calculate withdrawal liability, establish a payment schedule, demand payment, and the employer misses a payment due under that schedule.
  • Whether the first missed installment starts limitations for the entire withdrawal liability.. Each missed installment creates a separate cause of action with its own six-year limitations period. Optional acceleration does not require the plan to accelerate or forfeit future installments; limitations on an accelerated debt run from exercise of the acceleration option.
  • Whether the Fund could recover the first installment based on timeliness arguments omitted from its certiorari petition.. The Fund waived its right to recover the first $345.50 installment.

Docket 96-370

Cited authorities

Cited by