Supreme Court of the United States

Raymond Motor Transportation, Inc. v. Rice

February 21, 1978434 U.S. 429

Summary

The Court held that Wisconsin's restrictions on 65-foot double-trailer trucks unconstitutionally burden interstate commerce because the State's asserted highway-safety justification was unsupported by the record, while the regulations imposed substantial costs, delays, and routing burdens. The Court reversed the three-judge District Court's judgment and remanded for further proceedings. Justice Blackmun, joined by the Chief Justice and Justices Brennan and Rehnquist, concurred to emphasize that the decision was narrow and did not diminish deference to genuine state highway-safety judgments.

Holding

  • Whether Wisconsin's truck-length and configuration regulations unconstitutionally burden interstate commerce.. The regulations violate the Commerce Clause because they impose a substantial burden on interstate commerce and make no more than a speculative contribution to highway safety.

Docket 76-558

Cited authorities

Cited by