Supreme Court of the United States

Drake Bakeries Incorporated v. Local 50, American Bakery & Confectionery Workers International, Afl-Cio

June 18, 1962370 U.S. 254

Summary

The Court, in an opinion by Justice White, affirmed the stay of the employer's § 301 damages action pending arbitration. The collective bargaining agreement's broad arbitration clause covered claims for damages from an alleged breach of its no-strike clause, and the circumstances surrounding the alleged one-day strike did not excuse the employer from arbitration. The union had not defaulted in seeking arbitration because it promptly requested a stay after the employer filed suit. Justice Harlan dissented without a stated joinder, finding insufficient evidence that the parties intended to submit the employer's strike-damages claim to arbitration rather than a court; he would have reversed substantially for the reasons in the withdrawn appellate panel opinion. Justice Frankfurter did not participate.

Holding

  • Whether the employer's strike-damages claim fell within the arbitration agreement.. Article V required arbitration of the employer's claim for damages from an alleged strike in violation of the collective bargaining agreement.
  • Whether the alleged breach of the no-strike clause excused arbitration.. The circumstances in this record did not relieve the employer of its duty to arbitrate the consequences of the alleged one-day strike.
  • Whether the union was in default in pursuing arbitration.. The union was not in default and remained entitled to a stay pending arbitration.

Docket 598

Cited authorities

Cited by