U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit

Matthew Bender & Company, Inc., Plaintiff, Hyperlaw, Inc., Intervenor-Plaintiff-Appellee v. West Publishing Co. And…

November 3, 1998158 F.3d 674

Summary

The court affirmed the declaratory judgment that the portions of West's case reports that HyperLaw intended to copy were not copyrightable. Although West's reports contain elements of both derivative works and compilations, the factual additions and rearrangements at issue reflected standard legal conventions, limited alternatives, and routine editorial choices rather than the minimal creativity required for protection. The court also held that the controversy was live and that the district court acted within its discretion in admitting supplemental testimony concerning HyperLaw's intended scope of copying.

Holding

  • Justiciability and supplemental evidence. A live controversy existed because HyperLaw demonstrated an intent to copy a substantial number of West's case reports and faced a reasonable apprehension of suit. The district court did not abuse its discretion by admitting supplemental testimony after the close of evidence.
  • Characterization and originality standard. West's case reports contain elements of both derivative works and compilations, but the same originality requirement applies under either characterization. Copyright protection requires independently created selection, arrangement, or modification that displays at least a minimal degree of creativity.
  • Copyrightability of West's challenged editorial alterations. The challenged alterations to captions, court and date information, attorney information, subsequent procedural history, and parallel or alternative citations were not sufficiently original or creative to be copyrightable.
  • Merger doctrine. The court declined to apply the merger doctrine to invalidate West's copyright claim at the copyrightability stage.

Docket Docket 97-7910

Cited authorities

Cited by