New York Court of Appeals

In the Matter of Samuel Cohen, Respondent, Against Cocoline Products, Inc., Appellants

July 8, 1955309 N.Y. 119

Summary

The Court reversed the order granting inspection of corporate books to a former director and remanded for further proceedings, holding that a director's absolute right to inspect terminates upon removal and that any qualified right for a former director must be exercised with discretion and a hearing. Justice Desmond dissented, arguing that the petition should be dismissed outright because the petitioner is neither a director nor a stockholder.