The People of the State of New York v. . William Conroy

Summary

The Court of Appeals affirmed the General Term's order granting a new trial, holding that the indictment was sufficient without stating a specific intent, that a lay witness may testify about the rationality of the defendant's conduct, and that the jury could infer deliberation and premeditation from the evidence. The court also clarified the proper standards for reviewing indictment form and appellate review of a new‑trial order.