New York Court of Appeals

John Hope, Plaintiff in Error v. the People of the State of New York, Defendant in Error

January 18, 188183 N.Y. 418

Summary

The Court affirmed the conviction for first-degree robbery, holding that the sufficiency of the grand‑jury indictment cannot be challenged by a plea, that defective counts do not invalidate a general verdict on valid counts, that the taking of a key with intent to appropriate satisfies robbery, and that evidence of a related burglary is admissible to connect the defendant to the robbery.