Maria Pulice and Frank Pulice v. Green Brook Sports & Fitness, L.L.C., D/b/a Eclipse Sports and Wellness, Christian…

Summary

Judge X dissented from the Court’s order dismissing the appeal after the parties settled, arguing that the enforceability of health‑club exculpatory clauses is a matter of paramount public importance that should not be dismissed as moot. The dissent critiques the reliance on Stelluti and urges the Court to reconsider the public‑policy implications of allowing gyms to waive negligence liability.