Montana Supreme Court
Charlie's Win v. Gallatin West HOA
March 11, 2025421 Mont. 59
Summary
The Montana Supreme Court affirmed the district court’s summary‑judgment ruling that the covenants governing the Gallatin West Ranch Subdivision had expired because the 2015 vote failed to meet the two‑thirds majority required to renew them, and therefore the association could not enforce the Fourth Amended Declaration against Charlie’s Win. The Court rejected the association’s arguments that the vote was sufficient, that the amendment renewed the covenants, and that the covenants were ambiguous.