Mathew W. McCallister, Appellant (defendant) v. State of Indiana, Appellee (plaintiff).

Summary

The Indiana Supreme Court affirmed McCallister’s convictions for murder and conspiracy to commit murder and his life-without-parole sentence. The court held that sufficient eyewitness and circumstantial evidence supported the convictions, the challenged electronic evidence was properly admitted or its admission was harmless, and the sentence was neither disproportionate nor inappropriate. There were no separate opinions.