Supreme Court of Florida

Timothy W. Fletcher v. State of Florida

July 31, 2025

Summary

The court affirmed Fletcher’s death sentence following a Hurst resentencing, rejecting all nine claims of error. It held that the prosecutor’s comment about antisocial personality disorder did not warrant a mistrial, the jury’s mitigation verdict did not establish reverse jury nullification, victim-impact evidence was permissible, Florida’s capital-sentencing scheme and aggravators were constitutional, and the unpreserved instructional claims did not constitute fundamental error.