The League of Women Voters of Florida v. the Florida House of Representatives, Respondents Rene Romo v. the Florida…

Summary

The Court held that Florida recognizes a legislative privilege grounded in separation of powers, but the privilege is not absolute when it conflicts with the compelling constitutional interest in enforcing the prohibition against partisan or discriminatory intent in redistricting. It approved limited discovery concerning the 2012 congressional reapportionment process, while protecting legislators’ and legislative staff members’ thoughts or impressions at this stage. Justice Canady, dissenting, would have enforced an absolute legislative privilege, while Justices Labarga and Perry, concurring, emphasized effectuating the voters’ redistricting amendment and considering an independent redistricting commission.