Supreme Court of Delaware

Appiah v. State

October 21, 2025

Summary

The Supreme Court of Delaware affirmed the denial of Appiah’s second motion for postconviction relief. It held that the alleged failure to test a glove and call alibi witnesses constituted repackaged ineffective-assistance claims, not new evidence supporting the actual-innocence exception to the procedural bars. The Court also held that the Superior Court properly rejected Appiah’s reconsideration-based recusal claim after determining that the judge had not participated in his prosecution.