Maia v. Commissioner of Correction

Summary

The court held that defense counsel is not categorically required to recommend that a defendant accept or reject a plea offer. Counsel must provide sufficient professional information and advice for an informed decision, but whether a specific recommendation is required depends on the circumstances. Because counsel adequately explained the evidence, defenses, trial risks, sentencing exposure, and likelihood of success, the failure to recommend acceptance of the offer was not deficient performance, and the habeas judgment was reversed.