California Supreme Court

Alejandra Ruiz, Plaintiffs and Respondents v. Anatol Podolsky, Defendant and Appellant — Kennard, J., Dissenting

August 23, 201050 Cal. 4th 838

Summary

Justice Kennard's dissent would affirm the denial of the physician's motion to compel arbitration. It reasons that the decedent's agreement covered his own medical-malpractice claims but did not bind his adult children's independent wrongful-death claims because they never consented to arbitration. The dissent concludes that the governing statute does not clearly authorize a patient to waive the jury-trial rights of non-signing heirs.