Arkansas State Board of Election Commissioners and Doyle Webb

Summary

Justice Baker dissented from the majority's affirmance of the circuit court's ruling concerning election rules implementing voter-identification requirements. She agreed that the circuit court erred in addressing the constitutionality of Act 595 but concluded that the majority could not apply the right-result-wrong-reason doctrine because the majority's ruling would produce a materially different result for absentee ballots. She would have reversed and remanded for further proceedings, and Justice Hart joined the dissent.