Supreme Court of the United States

Wellons v. Hall

January 19, 2010558 U.S. 220

Summary

Justice Scalia, dissenting, argues the Court's grant, vacate, and remand order is improper because the Eleventh Circuit's decision rested on independent merits grounds unaffected by the procedural error addressed in Cone v. Bell. He contends the Court uses this disposition to void judgments on suspicion rather than to correct error, disrespecting the lower court's authority.