Supreme Court of the United States
Christian Legal Society Chapter of the University of California, Hastings College of the Law, Aka H — Alito, J…
June 28, 2010177 L. Ed. 2d 838
Summary
Justice Alito dissents, arguing Hastings denied CLS registration under its Nondiscrimination Policy due to viewpoint discrimination against religious and sexual morality viewpoints rather than an “accept-all-comers” policy. He contends the Court disregards Healy v. James and upholds a policy that burdens expressive association rights. Justice Stevens and Justice Kennedy concur separately, joining the majority’s judgment and supporting the policy’s legitimacy.