Supreme Court of the United States

Clingman v. Beaver — Stevens, J., Dissenting

May 23, 2005544 U.S. 581

Summary

Justice Stevens, dissenting, argues the Oklahoma semiclosed primary law burdens First Amendment rights of voters and the Libertarian Party by excluding non-members from participating in primaries. He finds the state interests advanced are protectionist and insufficient to justify the burden. Stevens would affirm the Court of Appeals judgment.