Illinois v. McArthur — Stevens, J., Dissenting

Summary

Justice Stevens dissents, arguing the minor nature of the offense makes it a poor vehicle for Fourth Amendment analysis. He would dismiss certiorari but, compelled to reach the merits, would affirm based on the sanctity of the home outweighing the need to prosecute petty crimes. Justice Souter concurred, joining the majority but discussing exigent circumstances and warrant preferences.