Reno v. Bossier Parish School Board — Breyer, J., dissenting

Summary

Justice Breyer dissents, agreeing with Justice Souter on one qualification: he would not reconsider Beer v. United States, but argues § 5 prohibits preclearance of voting changes with the purpose of unconstitutionally depriving minorities of the right to vote. He relies on the statute's history and legislative materials to support this conclusion. Justice Stevens and Justice Souter separately dissent on statutory grounds, while Justice Thomas concurs noting election results during litigation.